Skip to content

What's Behind Her Smile? Looks, Self-Esteem, and Labor Market Outcomes

icpsr_159261

Francisco A. Gallego, Cristian Larroulet, Andrea Repetto (2018)

field value
replication data openICPSR 159261
data license CC BY 4.0 — “This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) License.”
regression datasets (in this corpus) 3
graduated / eligible / exported 3 / 7 / 252 (policy claims_manual_regression_cap)
routed / gap / residue (at source) 8 / 107 / 0

Claims & tasks

Every claim the paper makes in its main body about a parameter, joined to the benchmark task (dataset · coefficient) that captures it. The effect, s.e. and p are the captured regression's own reported values (the paper's Stata figures, carrying the paper's SE method); the row shows the paper's verbatim quote (page · exhibit), so you can confirm the regression matches what the paper says. The prominence column is the within-study inclusion signal (⭐ headline → primary → secondary). The sensitivity column is the privacy level of the most-sensitive variable in the regression (🔴 high / 🟠 medium / ⚪ low).

# prominence sensitivity claim effect s.e. p task instance (dataset · coef)
C1 secondary 🔴 high This effect is equal to 66 p.p., which implies that two-thirds of the winners actually completed the treatment.
p. 17 · Table 3, col 1 (All (1))		 +0.647 0.025 1.2e-104 Linear Regression reg_10 · treatment
n=799 · d=53
C2 secondary 🔴 high Results in Table 3 show that the effect of the intervention on the likelihood of having received any dental service is 16 p.p. in the first follow-up and 6 p.p. in the second followup.
p. 17 · Table 3, col 1 (All (1))		 +0.162 0.035 5.9e-06 Linear Regression reg_13 · treatment
n=642 · d=53
C3 secondary 🔴 high These effects are statistically significant and economically relevant (0.44σ and 0.46σ respectively), and suggest that the labor productivity of the treated group increased as consequence of the program.
p. 26 · Table 11, col 1 (Treatment Effects)		 +0.457 0.150 0.002 Linear Regression reg_47__1 · treat1
n=568 · d=4

Regression datasets

The 3 regression dataset(s) graduated into the benchmark corpus from this study's replication package — each backs one or more claims above. Expand each for its features, response, (sound, data-independent) public bounds, and reproduction grade.

icpsr_159261_reg_10 — completed ~ treatment + new_sd_ohip0 + new_sd_rosen0 + lb_employ + lb_years_education + l…

Sensitivity proposal: 🔴 high maximum across columns (advisory; reviewed manually). Reproduction grade: ✅ match (benchmark-eligible).

Features

name description type sensitivity bound lo bound hi estimate s.e.
_cons intercept continuous — 1 1 +0.02227 0.103
treatment overall treatment assignment indicator continuous ⚪ low 0.0 1.0 +0.6474 0.0252
new_sd_ohip0 standardized baseline Oral Health Impact Profile score continuous 🔴 high -6.0 6.0 +0.01077 0.0144
new_sd_rosen0 standardized baseline Rosenberg self-esteem score continuous 🔴 high -6.0 6.0 +0.02609 0.027
lb_employ baseline employment status indicator continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.01806 0.0283
lb_years_education baseline years of formal education completed continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 30.0 -0.0008998 0.00464
lb_jefe_hogar baseline head-of-household status indicator continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.05211 0.0271
lb_estrato_level4_2 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.02795 0.119
lb_estrato_level4_3 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.01774 0.13
lb_estrato_level4_4 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.1765 0.0849
lb_estrato_level4_5 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.07152 0.0997
lb_estrato_level4_6 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.08024 0.117
lb_estrato_level4_7 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.1401 0.0845
lb_estrato_level4_8 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.1318 0.0913
lb_estrato_level4_9 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.01443 0.11
lb_estrato_level4_10 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.05286 0.162
lb_estrato_level4_11 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.004743 0.175
lb_estrato_level4_12 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.01394 0.14
lb_estrato_level4_13 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.03652 0.126
lb_estrato_level4_14 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.0753 0.126
lb_estrato_level4_15 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.00468 0.127
lb_estrato_level4_16 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.05097 0.159
lb_estrato_level4_17 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.05089 0.136
lb_estrato_level4_18 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.19 0.0855
lb_estrato_level4_19 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.1527 0.0988
lb_estrato_level4_20 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.127 0.12
lb_estrato_level4_21 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.18 0.104
lb_estrato_level4_22 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.08323 0.12
lb_estrato_level4_23 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.03963 0.122
lb_estrato_level4_24 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.08451 0.0982
lb_estrato_level4_25 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.09184 0.096
lb_estrato_level4_26 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.01751 0.112
lb_estrato_level4_27 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.1301 0.144
lb_estrato_level4_28 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.006683 0.166
lb_estrato_level4_29 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.2148 0.147
lb_estrato_level4_30 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.1009 0.117
lb_estrato_level4_31 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.2009 0.0964
lb_estrato_level4_32 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.1833 0.16
lb_estrato_level4_33 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.2531 0.105
lb_estrato_level4_34 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.08141 0.134
lb_estrato_level4_35 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.002747 0.115
lb_estrato_level4_36 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.1619 0.108
lb_estrato_level4_37 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.08116 0.122
lb_estrato_level4_38 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.01774 0.123
lb_estrato_level4_39 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.03246 0.153
lb_estrato_level4_40 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.1317 0.102
lb_estrato_level4_41 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.1066 0.101
lb_estrato_level4_42 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.03504 0.129
lb_estrato_level4_43 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.04237 0.115
lb_estrato_level4_44 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.04516 0.115
lb_estrato_level3_1 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (level 3) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.2316 0.146
lb_estrato_level3_2 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (level 3) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.05348 0.148
lb_estrato_level1_1 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (coarse level 1) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.04244 0.0898
lb_estrato_level1_2 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (coarse level 1) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.1467 0.119

Response

name description type sensitivity bound lo bound hi estimate s.e.
completed indicator subject completed assigned treatment program continuous ⚪ low 0.0 1.0 — —

Public bounds (data-independent) sourced from: binary household-role indicator; binary labor-status indicator; binary one-hot stratum indicator; binary take-up/completion indicator; binary treatment indicator; plausible ceiling near postgraduate schooling; standardized (sd) score, name indicates z-score scale._

n = 799 samples.

icpsr_159261_reg_13 — dental_service ~ treatment + new_sd_ohip0 + new_sd_rosen0 + lb_employ + lb_years_educatio…

Sensitivity proposal: 🔴 high maximum across columns (advisory; reviewed manually). Reproduction grade: ✅ match (benchmark-eligible).

Features

name description type sensitivity bound lo bound hi estimate s.e.
_cons intercept continuous — 1 1 +0.4564 0.172
treatment overall treatment assignment indicator continuous ⚪ low 0.0 1.0 +0.1622 0.0355
new_sd_ohip0 standardized baseline Oral Health Impact Profile score continuous 🔴 high -6.0 6.0 +0.002287 0.0232
new_sd_rosen0 standardized baseline Rosenberg self-esteem score continuous 🔴 high -6.0 6.0 +0.0771 0.044
lb_employ baseline employment status indicator continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.04061 0.0448
lb_years_education baseline years of formal education completed continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 30.0 +0.01325 0.00761
lb_jefe_hogar baseline head-of-household status indicator continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.01569 0.0445
lb_estrato_level4_2 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.1412 0.183
lb_estrato_level4_3 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.3197 0.142
lb_estrato_level4_4 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.2983 0.138
lb_estrato_level4_5 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.02252 0.158
lb_estrato_level4_6 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.06111 0.195
lb_estrato_level4_7 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.1251 0.137
lb_estrato_level4_8 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.2102 0.145
lb_estrato_level4_9 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.02948 0.169
lb_estrato_level4_10 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.06191 0.288
lb_estrato_level4_11 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.3683 0.134
lb_estrato_level4_12 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.0273 0.225
lb_estrato_level4_13 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.04308 0.213
lb_estrato_level4_14 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.1638 0.178
lb_estrato_level4_15 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.04357 0.22
lb_estrato_level4_16 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.103 0.244
lb_estrato_level4_17 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.4358 0.204
lb_estrato_level4_18 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.1226 0.144
lb_estrato_level4_19 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.1985 0.162
lb_estrato_level4_20 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.1041 0.201
lb_estrato_level4_21 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.1266 0.178
lb_estrato_level4_22 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.01149 0.186
lb_estrato_level4_23 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.01272 0.198
lb_estrato_level4_24 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.2119 0.152
lb_estrato_level4_25 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.1285 0.158
lb_estrato_level4_26 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.03193 0.175
lb_estrato_level4_27 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.4215 0.127
lb_estrato_level4_28 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.09777 0.249
lb_estrato_level4_29 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.5145 0.269
lb_estrato_level4_30 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.08134 0.2
lb_estrato_level4_31 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.2053 0.172
lb_estrato_level4_32 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.2308 0.287
lb_estrato_level4_33 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.1402 0.251
lb_estrato_level4_34 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.06391 0.235
lb_estrato_level4_35 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.2151 0.186
lb_estrato_level4_36 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.09708 0.19
lb_estrato_level4_37 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.008501 0.194
lb_estrato_level4_38 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.1258 0.17
lb_estrato_level4_39 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.264 0.26
lb_estrato_level4_40 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.1758 0.156
lb_estrato_level4_41 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.09189 0.168
lb_estrato_level4_42 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.1641 0.211
lb_estrato_level4_43 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.2152 0.164
lb_estrato_level4_44 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (fine level 4) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.01781 0.185
lb_estrato_level3_1 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (level 3) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.4149 0.263
lb_estrato_level3_2 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (level 3) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.002992 0.224
lb_estrato_level1_1 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (coarse level 1) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 +0.387 0.13
lb_estrato_level1_2 baseline socioeconomic stratum category dummy (coarse level 1) continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 -0.01697 0.29

Response

name description type sensitivity bound lo bound hi estimate s.e.
dental_service received any dental service by follow-up 1 continuous 🟠 medium 0.0 1.0 — —

Public bounds (data-independent) sourced from: binary health-service utilization indicator; binary household-role indicator; binary labor-status indicator; binary one-hot stratum indicator; binary treatment indicator; plausible ceiling near postgraduate schooling; standardized (sd) score, name indicates z-score scale._

n = 642 samples.

icpsr_159261_reg_47__1 — sd_ohip ~ treat1 + treat2 + dummy1 + dummy2

Sensitivity proposal: 🔴 high maximum across columns (advisory; reviewed manually). Reproduction grade: ✅ match (benchmark-eligible).

Features

name description type sensitivity bound lo bound hi estimate s.e.
treat1 assignment indicator for treatment arm 1 continuous ⚪ low -1.0 1.0 +0.457 0.15
treat2 assignment indicator for treatment arm 2 continuous ⚪ low -1.0 1.0 +0.2271 0.161
dummy1 auxiliary treatment/wave dummy used with treat1/treat2 continuous ⚪ low -1.0 1.0 +0.7287 0.0777
dummy2 auxiliary treatment/wave dummy used with treat1/treat2 continuous ⚪ low -1.0 1.0 +1.227 0.118

Response

name description type sensitivity bound lo bound hi estimate s.e.
sd_ohip standardized Oral Health Impact Profile outcome score continuous 🔴 high -12.0 12.0 — —

Public bounds (data-independent) sourced from: binary indicator; binary treatment-arm indicator; standardized (sd) score, name indicates z-score scale._

n = 568 samples.